Lulu
Best cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn that make you happier. If you’re craving delicious Italian food without spending a fortune, the cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn scene has you covered with cozy trattorias, casual pasta spots, and budget‑friendly pizzerias.
From traditional slices to fresh pasta bowls and hidden neighborhood favorites, these restaurants prove great Italian food doesn’t have to be expensive. Whether you live in the borough or are visiting, this guide will help you discover affordable Italian eats that hit every craving, without stretching your budget.
1. Panzerotti Bites – Fast, Fresh Italian Street Eats
Panzerotti Bites serves up tasty Italian panzerotti (fried or baked stuffed dough) and other Italian snacks that are perfect for a quick, affordable meal any day of the week. Their flavorful fillings and crispy crusts make this a favorite cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn go‑to, especially for lunch or a casual dinner with friends.
Location: 235 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 (Carroll Gardens)
2. Lillo Cucina Italiana – Neighborhood Pasta & More
Lillo Cucina Italiana is beloved for its generous portions, classic pasta dishes, and warm, welcoming vibes. Known for its generous portions of classic Italian fare such as rigatoni and meatballs, this spot keeps prices reasonable, making it a favorite among Brooklyn diners.
Location: 331 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201 (Brooklyn Heights)
3. Psta – Fast Pasta, Big Flavor
At Psta, the focus is simple: fresh, house‑made pasta served fast and priced right. Pick your favorite pasta and top it with delicious options at a place where laid-back vibes and budget-friendly Italian meals come together.
Location: 210 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217 (Fort Greene)
4. L&B Spumoni Gardens – Sicilian Pizza Classic
A Brooklyn classic for decades, L&B Spumoni Gardens offers thick, cheesy Sicilian pizza by the slice or pie without premium prices. While pizza is front and center, you can also try their Italian sandwiches, salads, and spumoni dessert, all part of why this place remains a favorite cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn pick.
Location: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223 (Bay Ridge)
5. Little Fino – Wood‑Fired Italian in Williamsburg
Little Fino blends casual Italian favorites with wood‑fired dishes that feel special but are still affordable compared to upscale Italian spots. With simple pastas, small plates, and plenty of flavor, it’s a strong contender on any cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn list.
Location: 111 N12th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249 (Williamsburg)
6. Evelina – Casual Italian Bistro Style
Evelina offers approachable Italian eats like fresh pasta, seasonal dishes, and hearty entrées in a relaxed atmosphere. While slightly trendier, its portion sizes and reasonable pricing help it qualify as one of the neighborhood’s stand‑out cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn options.
Location: 211 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205 (Fort Greene)
7. Osteria Brooklyn – Rustic Italian Comfort Food
Osteria Brooklyn delivers flavorful pasta, appetizers, and Italian classics that feel like homemade. The portions are generous and prices are friendly compared to many Italian spots in NYC, making it a favorite for those seeking hearty meals without high costs.
Location: 458 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205 (Clinton Hill)
8. Roma Pizza & Restaurant – Classic Slice & Dine
Known for its delicious yet budget-friendly Italian fare, Roma Pizza & Restaurant in Park Slope is one of the best cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn that delivers hearty pizza and pasta that satisfy both the palate and the pocket.
Location: 85 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217 (Park Slope)
9. Mariella – Traditional Italian in the Neighborhood
Also in Park Slope, Mariella earns local love for its well‑cooked pasta dishes and cozy, friendly ambiance at prices that keep diners coming back, making it another affordable pick.
Location: 492 6th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (Park Slope)
10. Patsy’s Pizzeria (Park Slope) – Old‑School Slice Spot
Originally from Manhattan, Patsy’s is one of the best cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn that brings its thin crust pizza goodness to Park Slope, serving budget-friendly slices for a relaxed Italian dining experience.
Location: 450 Dean St, Brooklyn, NY 11217 (Park Slope)
11. Joe’s of Avenue U – Sicilian Classics on a Budget
With generous portions of Sicilian-style pasta and classic red-sauce meals, Joe’s on Avenue U is beloved by locals looking for tasty, affordable Italian food.
Location: Avenue U & E 20th St, Brooklyn, NY 11229 (Sheepshead Bay)
12. Coletta – Rustic Italian with Big Portions
Coletta is one of the best cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn on another neighborhood pick where generous Italian portions are paired with approachable pricing, earning its place among local recommendations for cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn finds.
Location: 203 Prospect Park West, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (Park Slope)
Tips for Enjoying Cheap Italian in Brooklyn
1. Opt for Lunch or Early Dinner Specials
Many Italian spots offer discounted pasta or slice combos during lunch or early dinner hours a great way to enjoy quality meals without spending more.
2. Share Plates with Friends
Splitting a few antipasti and pasta bowls lets you sample more dishes while keeping costs low at many cheap Italian restaurant Brooklyn taverns.
3. Check Daily Specials
Neighborhood eateries frequently feature standout bargains through their daily menus, including unique pasta creations or limited-time pizza varieties that aren’t part of the standard selection.
4. Combine with Dessert Nearby
Many budget-friendly Italian spots sit close to gelaterias or pastry shops, making it easy to end your affordable feast with a tasty dessert that won’t hurt your wallet.
Conclusion
Whether you’re enjoying handmade pasta, thick Sicilian slices, or tucked-away local trattorias, Brooklyn’s inexpensive Italian restaurants serve satisfying, flavorful meals for diners on any budget.