10 Best Seafood Restaurant Brooklyn Spots Known For Fresh And Flavorful Dishes

Seafood restaurant Brooklyn searches have skyrocketed lately, and it’s not hard to see why. Brooklyn’s food scene is constantly evolving, blending old-school charm with bold, modern flavors from around the world. Whether you’re craving buttery lobster rolls, freshly shucked oysters, or spicy Cajun shrimp, this borough delivers it all. Let’s dive into the top places making waves right now.

1. Clemente’s Maryland Crab House

If you’re looking for waterfront views and generous crab platters, this place has been a Brooklyn staple since 1974. Clemente’s Maryland Crab House is famous for its all-you-can-eat blue crabs served with classic Old Bay seasoning. Families and groups often gather here for relaxed summer dinners overlooking the marina. It’s the kind of seafood restaurant Brooklyn locals return to for tradition and flavor. Their fried calamari and lobster tails are also crowd favorites. Come hungry because portions here are no joke.

Location: 3939 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235

2. Randazzo’s Clam Bar

Since 1932, Randazzo’s Clam Bar has been serving legendary red-sauce seafood dishes that locals swear by. The spicy tomato-based clam sauce is what put this Sheepshead Bay icon on the map. You’ll often hear regulars recommending the baked clams and shrimp parmigiana. When talking about classic Italian-American seafood restaurant Brooklyn experiences, this spot always enters the conversation. The atmosphere is casual, loud, and full of personality. It feels like stepping into a true neighborhood institution.

Location: 2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235

3. The Boil

Instead of plates, expect plastic bibs and seafood served in bags soaked with garlic butter sauce. This modern seafood restaurant Brooklyn foodies love is especially known for its shrimp, crawfish, and king crab legs. It’s lively, energetic, and perfect for groups of friends. Be ready to use your hands and enjoy every bite.

Location: 139 N 7th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

4. Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.

Sourcing directly from small fisheries, this spot takes sustainability seriously. Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. doubles as a fish market and restaurant, ensuring ultra-fresh daily selections. Their lobster roll, served either warm with butter or chilled with mayo, consistently earns praise. The menu changes based on what’s in season, which keeps things exciting. It’s small, cozy, and focused purely on quality.

Location: 114 Nassau Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

5. Lure Fishbar Brooklyn

An extension of the Manhattan favorite, Lure Fishbar Brooklyn brings upscale vibes to DUMBO. The interior feels like a luxury yacht, making it ideal for date nights or celebrations. Many consider it a refined seafood restaurant Brooklyn visitors can rely on for consistent quality. Their clam chowder and grilled branzino are standout dishes. Service here is polished yet welcoming.

Location: 56 Adams St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

6. Seamore’s Dumbo

Overlooking the Manhattan Bridge, Seamore’s offers a laid-back yet stylish seafood experience. The menu focuses on responsibly sourced fish with creative twists. Fish tacos and lobster mac & cheese are among the most ordered dishes. As a seafood restaurant Brooklyn residents enjoy for casual nights out, it balances flavor and sustainability well. The atmosphere feels bright and inviting. It’s especially popular during weekend brunch hours.

Location: 66 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

7. Jordan’s Lobster Dock

Right by the water in Sheepshead Bay, Jordan’s Lobster Dock is all about simplicity and freshness. Established in 1979, it has built a reputation for sweet, perfectly steamed lobsters. Many people come specifically for the lobster roll packed with generous chunks of meat. This beloved seafood restaurant Brooklyn gem keeps things no-frills and authentic. Outdoor seating adds to the relaxed coastal vibe. It’s a summer favorite for locals and visitors alike.

Location: 3165 Harkness Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235

8. Bar Crudo

Tucked away in Park Slope, Bar Crudo offers an intimate dining experience centered around fresh oysters and small plates. The rotating oyster selection highlights varieties from both coasts. When people talk about hidden seafood restaurant Brooklyn treasures, this cozy spot often comes up. The wine list pairs beautifully with the briny flavors on the menu. It’s ideal for a relaxed evening with friends.

Location: 555 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

9. Crab House Brooklyn

If you’re in the mood for indulgence, Crab House Brooklyn is known for its all-you-can-eat seafood buffet. It’s one of the more affordable seafood restaurant Brooklyn choices for big appetites. Diners appreciate the generous portions and lively setting. The garlic butter sauce is especially addictive. Reservations are recommended during peak hours.

Location: 1352 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11228

10. Sel Rrose

While primarily known as an oyster bar, Sel Rrose brings a trendy twist to seafood dining in Bushwick. The candlelit interior creates a romantic, slightly mysterious atmosphere. Oysters are sourced daily and served with creative mignonette sauces. As a modern seafood restaurant Brooklyn nightlife lovers appreciate, it blends cocktails and fresh seafood effortlessly. The shrimp toast and scallop crudo are highly recommended. It’s stylish without feeling pretentious.

Location: 104 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249

Tips for Choosing the Best Seafood Restaurant in Brooklyn

Check if the restaurant sources seafood sustainably.
Look at customer reviews for freshness mentions.
Visit waterfront areas for classic seafood vibes.
Make reservations on weekends to avoid long waits.
Try seasonal specials for the freshest catch.
Don’t be afraid to ask staff for daily recommendations.
Consider whether you prefer casual dining or upscale ambiance.

Conclusion

Each neighborhood brings its own personality, flavors, and atmosphere to the table. Whether you’re planning a romantic dinner, a family feast, or a fun night out with friends, there’s a seafood restaurant Brooklyn spot that fits the occasion perfectly. The key is knowing what kind of experience you want, classic, modern, messy, or refined. One thing’s certain: once you start exploring Brooklyn’s seafood scene, you’ll keep coming back for more.